Who was a better College Quarter Back, Tim Tebow or Vince Young?

I personally think Young.


Even if Young hasn't accomplished as much as Tim.





Tebow-


2006 Season


SEC All-Freshman Team[51]


SEC Freshman of the Week[52]





2007 Season


Walter Camp Foundation National Offensive Player of the Week [53]


Southeastern Conference Offensive Player of the Week, three times [54] [55] [56]


Davey O'Brien Award winner [57]


Heisman Trophy winner


Maxwell Award winner [57]


Walter Camp Award finalist[58]


ESPN The Magazine Academic All-American football team [59]


Manning Award finalist[59]


Rivals.com National Offensive Player of the Year [60]


Rivals.com SEC Offensive Player of the Year [61]


Rivals.com First Team All-SEC [61]


First Team All-SEC Coaches Conference football team[62]


Associated Press SEC Offensive Player of the Year[63]


Associated Press All-SEC First Team[63]


Associated Press Player of the Year[64]


Listed as an All-American by: Associated Press, Football Writers Association of America, Walter Camp Football Foundation, Sporting News, Sports Illustrated, ESPN, CBS Sports, College Football News, Rivals.com, and Scout.com


James E. Sullivan Award, awarded to the Nations top amateur athlete[65]


Roy F. Kramer SEC Male Athlete of the Year[66]. Third Florida Gator to win this award, Danny Wuerffel (won twice) and Ryan Lochte.


ESPY for Best Male College Athlete[67]





2008 Season


Disney Spirit Award[68]


Heisman Trophy finalist


Maxwell Award winner


Southeastern Conference Offensive Player of the Week[69]


2008 SEC Championship Game Most Valuable Player


Southeastern Conference Offensive Player of the Year


Southeastern Conference Scholar-Athlete of the Year[70]


Wuerffel Trophy winner





Young-


2006 - ESPY Award for Best Championship Performance. Vince Young and Matt Leinart jointly accepted the ESPY for the Best Game for their respective teams.[3][4]


2006 - Big 12 Male Athlete of the Year (for 2005-2006 scholastic year)


2006 - Manning Award winner


2006 - Rose Bowl MVP (at end of 2005 season)


2005 - Heisman Trophy finalist and runner-up


2005 - The Cingular All-America Player of the Year Award


2005 - All-American Offensive Player


2005 - The Maxwell Award - College Player of the Year


2005 - Davey O'Brien National Quarterback Award


2005 - 1st Team All-Big 12 Conference honors (unanimous decision)


2005 - Rose Bowl Most Valuable Player (at end of 2004 season)[5]


2004 - Honorable mention All-Big 12 Conference honors


2003 - Big 12 Conference Offensive Freshman of the Year|||Vince Young single handedly lead Texas to an undefeated season (something Tebow wouldnt know anything about) and single handedly won the national championship against one of the best teams in the history of college football. Tebow already has more losses as a starter than Young did, and in his 2 title wins he came off the bench, and threw 2 picks and got bailed out by his defense in the other. Awards prove nothing in college football beacuse they come before the bowl games.|||VINCE YOUNG BY FAR!|||Young





Love the avatar.|||Vince Young could have won 2 national championships but he left to the draft bro|||Hands down Vince Young he carried the team on his shoulders his whole collegiate carrer and where as Tebow has Harvin and other great playmakers|||VY hands down|||Vince Young but hes done Sh!t since hes gotten into the NFL I mean collins has completely took back his job lmao





Wait I take that back TITANS SUCK THEY LOST TO THE RAVENS LMAO|||vince young undenniably! he is said to have been the best quaterback in college football history. not to mention he won the award for the "greatest game ever played".





tebow is good though|||I don't know anything about that. But all I have to say that Tim Tebow is the hottest thing alive.





Dear Tim Tebow,


If you read this I love you.|||vince is wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy better|||Just because he won so many awards doesn't mean he's better. It's about how they play. Tebow is a better qb. He can run just as well as VY but he throws a lot better.





Tebow all the way.|||Hard to say...Tebow is not done yet. But I give the edge to Tebow...he consistently faces better defenses and wins.